R I T I C I S M . O M ::
Home
General
quotes |

|
On the Wire Philosophy In the News No current headlines. | Quotations
Insightful Remarks and Observations By Steve Hoenisch Last updated on July 26, 2004 Copyright 1996-2006 www.Criticism.Com Table of Contents 1 Linguistics 1.1 General 1.1.1 Conservatives, Won't You Ditch the Prescriptive Grammar? 1.2 Discourse Analysis and Sociolinguistics 1.2.1 Motivating Interactional Sociolinguistics 1.2.2 Goffman on Systems-Contraints and ritual-Contraints 1.2.3 On Language Change 1.3 Semantics and Philosophy of Language 1.3.1 Counterpoint: The Logicians Are Certifiable! 1.3.2 Searle Extending Wittgenstein 1.4 Marxism and Language 1.4.1 "Language" Is Constructed from Language 1.4.2 Activity and History 1.4.3 Plato's Solution in Cratylus as the Foundation of Idealist Thought 2 Media Criticism 2.1 Problems Can Only Be Solved in Depth 2.2 The Protesters Aren't People 2.3 Disinherited by Censorship 2.4 Madness and Civilization 2.5 Contributors Must Have Control 3 Philosophy 3.1 Baudrillard on the Spectacle of Brain 3.2 Wittgenstein Disperses the Fog 3.3 Tocqueville on the Role of Associations 4 Psychology 4.1 Freud on Dreams as Communication 4.2 Piaget on the Art of Persuasion 4.3 Parental Love Drives Obedience to Law 4.4 Prozacian Workers Support High-Tech Capitalism 5 Reading, Writing, Working, Loving 5.1 Roland Barthes' Phenomenological Contact with the Text 5.2 The Solitude of the Lover's Discourse 6 Literature 6.1 Identity and Resistance in The Castle 6.1.1 The Secret in the Object 6.1.2 Identity at the Margins 1 Linguistics1.1 General1.1.1 Conservatives, Won't You Ditch the Prescriptive Grammar?"It seems clear that knowledge of grammatical rules is an
essential component of the interactive competence that speakers
must have to interact and cooperate with others. Thus if we can
show that individuals interacting through linguistic signs are
effective in cooperating with others in the conduct of their
affairs, we have prima facie evidence for the existince of shared
grammatical structure. One need not as the nineteenth-century
normative grammarians did, and many modern educators continue to
do, attempt to judge an individual's basic linguistic ability in
reference to an a priori set of grammatical standards." --
Gumperz,
Discourse Strategies, p. 19.
1.2 Discourse Analysis and Sociolinguistics1.2.1 Motivating Interactional Sociolinguistics"There is a need for a sociolinguistic theory which accounts
for the communicative functions of linguistic variability and for
its relation to speakers' goals without reference to untestable
functionalist assumptions about conformity or nonconformance to
closed systems of norms. Since speaking is interacting, such a
theory must ultimately draw its basic postulates from what we
know about interaction." -- Gumperz, Discourse Strategies, p. 29.
1.2.2 Goffman on Systems-Contraints and ritual-ContraintsGoffman makes between "systems-constraints and ritual-constraints, where the first labels the ingredients essential to
more than on party, and the second those ingredients that, while
not essential to the maintaining of interaction, are nevertheless
typical of it -- they are ... the social dimensions of
interaction." -- Levinson,
Pragmatics, p. 44.
1.3 Semantics and Philosophy of Language1.3.1 Counterpoint: The Logicians Are Certifiable!Dostoyevsky's challenge to logical semantics: "And, to sum the whole thing up, why are you so
certain that not flying in the face of his real,
normal interests, certified by the deductions of reason and
arithmetic, is really always for his good and must be a law for
all mankind? After all, for the time being it is only your
supposition. Even if we assume it as a rule of logic, it may not
be a law for all mankind at all. Perhaps you think I'm mad,
gentlemen?" -- Fyodor Dostoyevsky,
Notes From Underground, trans.
Jessie Coulson (Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, 1972), p. 39.
Italics in original.
1.3.2 Searle Extending WittgensteinJohn Searle, in "Proper Names," develops what he sees as Wittgenstein's analysis into a theory, encapsulated in his suggestion that
"it is a necessary fact that Aristotle has the logical sum, inclusive disjunction, of properties commonly attributed to him: any individual not having at least some of these properties could not be Aristotle."
1.4 Marxism and Language1.4.1 "Language" Is Constructed from Language"All categories, including the category 'language,' are
themselves constructions in language, and can thus only with an
effort, and within a particular system of thought, be separated
from language for relational inquiry." -- Raymond Williams, Marxism and Literature, p. 21.
1.4.2 Activity and History"The key moments which should be of interest to Marxism, in
the development of thinking about language, are, first, the
emphasis on language as activity and, second, the
emphasis on the history of language." -- Raymond Williams, Marxism and Literature, p. 21.
1.4.3 Plato's Solution in Cratylus as the Foundation of Idealist Thought
"Plato's major inquiry into language (in the Craylus) was
centered on the problem of the correctness of naming, in which
the interrelation of 'word' and 'thing' can be seen to originate
either in 'nature' or in 'convention'." Plato's solution was in
effect the foundation of idealist thought: There is an
intermediate but constitutive realm, which is neither 'word' nor
'thing' but 'form,' 'essence,' or 'idea.' The investigation into
either 'language' or 'reality' was then always, at root, an
investigation of these constitutive (metaphysical) forms." -- Raymond Williams, Marxism and Literature, p. 22.
2 Media Criticism2.1 Problems Can Only Be Solved in Depth"The problems of life are insoluble on the surface and
can only be solved in depth. They are insoluble in surface
dimensions." -- Wittgenstein,
Culture and
Value, p. 74e, in a remark that has
implications both for the individual and for society, the latter
of which can be seen when the remark is applied to the current
state and content of the mass media in the United States.
2.2 The Protesters Aren't People"Where a reporter stands in relation to a confrontation in the
street ..." ... "The normal situation of the camera and reporter
is behind the police who are dealing with pickets or
demonstrators. This puts the viewer in a situation where he or
she too is invited to see them as objects; the viewer is, as it
were, identified with this position." -- Raymond Williams, On TV,
p. 209-210.
2.3 Disinherited by Censorship"Even so far as men have not yet succumbed to political
delusion, the mechanism of censorship--both internal and
external--will deprive them of the means of resistance." -- Max
Horkheimer and Theodor W. Adorno, Dialectic of Enlightenment,
trans. John Cumming (New York: Continuum, 1995), p. ix.
2.4 Madness and CivilizationFoucault, in the preface to Madness and Civilization, writes
that "in the serene world of mental illness, modern man no longer
communicates with the madman: on one hand the man of reason
delegates the physician to madness, thereby authorizing a
relation only through the abstract universality of disease; on
the other, the man of madness communicates with society only by
the intermediary of an equally abstract reason which is order,
physical and moral constraint, the anonymous pressure of the
group, the requirements of conformity." -- Foucault, Michel.
Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of
Reason, trans. Richard Howard (New York: Random House, 1965), p.
x.
2.5 Contributors Must Have Control"The right kind of organization, for any cultural institution" -- including newspapers, publishing houses, and television stations -- "is one based on control by the contributors." --Raymond Williams, the British sociologist and literary critic, in his book Communications.
3 Philosophy3.1 Baudrillard on the Spectacle of Brain"All that fascinates us is the spectacle of the
brain and its workings. What we are wanting here is to see our
thoughts unfolding before us -- and this itself is a
superstition.
"Hence, the academic grappling with his computer, ceaselessly
correcting, reworking, and complexifying, turning the exercise
into a kind of interminable psychoanalysis, memorizing everything
in an effort to escape the final outcome, to delay the day of
reckoning of death, and that other -- fatal -- moment of
reckoning that is writing, by forming an endless feed-back loop
with the machine. ... A spectacular desublimation of thought, his
concepts as images on a screen." -- Jean Baudrillard, America
(Verso: 1988), p. 36.
3.2 Wittgenstein Disperses the FogLudwig Wittgenstein, in attempting to unravel problems in the
philosophy of language, exhorts the reader of Philosophical
Investigations to view the phenemena in a its primitive state.
"It disperses the fog," Wittgenstein says, "to study the
phenomena of language in primitive kinds of application in which
one can command a clear view of the aim and functioning of the
words." --
Philosophical Investigations, Section 5.
3.3 Tocqueville on the Role of AssociationsTocqueville gives great importance to the role associations
play in democracy. Of the United States, he writes: "The most
democratic country on the face of the earth is that in which men
have, in our time, carried to the highest perfection the art of
pursuing in common the object of their common desires and have
applied this new science to the greatest number of purposes." --
Vol. 2, p. 107.
4 Psychology4.1 Freud on Dreams as CommunicationFor Freud, dreams are a form of communication, with signs and
symbols, a system of language all their own: "Even this
unintelligible dream must be a fully valid psychical, with sense
and worth, which we can use in analysis like any other
communcation." -- Freud, Sigmund. New Introductory Lectures on
Psycho-Analysis, trans. and ed. James Strachey (New York: W. W.
Norton and Co., 1965), p. 11.
4.2 Piaget on the Art of Persuasion
"The art of discussion ... consists principally in
knowing how to place oneself at the point of view
of one's partner in order to try to convince him
on his own ground."-- Jean Piaget. Comments on Vygotsky's Critical Remarks
Concerning The Language and Thought of the Child, and Judgment
and Reasoning in the Child (Cambridge: The MIT Press, 1962), p.
5.
4.3 Parental Love Drives Obedience to Law"Obedience to the laws of civilization is first
inspired, not by fear or prudence, Freud tells us,
but by love, love for those early powerful figures
who first demand obedience. Obedience, of course,
does not exorcise aggression; it merely directs it
against the self. There is becomes a means of
self-domination, infusing the voice of conscience
with the hostility that cannot be aimed at the
'unattackable authority.'" -- Jessica Benjamin, 1988, p. 5.
4.4 Prozacian Workers Support High-Tech Capitalism"Observing responses to Prozac," Kramer writes, "we learn not
only about ourselves but about our island's culture. ... The
success of Prozac says that today's high-tech capitalism values
... confidence, flexibility, quickness, and energy" -- Kramer,
Listening to Prozac, p. 297. Cf. Brown's view of capitalism as
rewarding conformist character, p. 297.
5 Reading, Writing, Working, Loving5.1 Roland Barthes' Phenomenological Contact with the Text"I work every day from 9:30 am to 1 p.m.; this regular
workaday schedule for writing suits me better than an aleatory
schedule, which supposes a state of continual excitement. ...
What I do enjoy is the excitement provoked by immediate and
phenomenological contact with the tutor text. ... I'm content to
read the text in question, in a rather fetishistic way: writing
down certain passages, moments, even words which have the power
to move me. As I go along, I use my cards to write down
quotations, or ideas which come to me, and they do so, curiously,
already in the rhythm of a sentence, so that from that moment on,
things are already taking on an existence as writing. ... From
then on, I'm plunged into a kind of frenzied state. I know that
everything I read will somehow find its inevitable way into my
work. The only problem is to keep what I read for amusement from
interfering with reading directed toward my writing. The solution
is very simple: the books I read for pleasure, for example a
classic, or one of Jakobson's books on linguistics, which I
particularly enjoy, those I read in bed at night before going to
sleep. I read the others at my worktable in the morning. ... The
bed is the locus of irresponsibility. The table, that of
responsibility." -- Roland Barthes,
The Grain of the Voice, pp.
180-181.
5.2 The Solitude of the Lover's Discourse"The lover's discourse is today of an
extreme solitude. This discourse is spoken,
perhaps, by thousands of subjects (who knows?),
but warranted by no one; it is completely forsaken
by the surrounding languages: ignored, disparaged,
or derided by them, severed not only from
authority but also from the mechanisms of
authority (sciences, techniques, arts). Once a
discourse is thus driven by its own momentum into
the backwater of the 'unreal,' exiled from all
gregarity, it has no recourse but to become the
site, however exiguous, of an affirmation."-- Barthes. Lover's Discourse. Emphasis in original. p. 1.
6 Literature6.1 Identity and Resistance in The Castle6.1.1 The Secret in the Object"The Castle is perhaps a theology in action, but it is first
of all the individual adventure of a soul in quest of its grace,
of a man who asks of this world's objects their royal secret and
of women the signs of the god that sleeps in them," Camus writes about Kafka's novel in The Myth of Sisyphus.1 In The Castle, "the details of everyday life stand out, and yet
in that strange novel in which nothing concludes and everything
begins over again, it is the essential adventure of a soul in
quest of its grace that is represented."2
K. finds that grace, at least for a fleeting moment or two, in the
humanity and in the brief moments of understanding that he
shares first with the Barnabas girl, then with Frieda, and
finally -- in a Modern twist, to begin again near the novel's end -- with Pepi. Each
of the women is in fact pivotal in everything beginning again.
6.1.2 Identity at the MarginsIt is through the relationships of love or friendship that K.
builds with Frieda, the Barnabas woman, and Pepi that K. finds both the inspiration for resistance, manifested in his "freedom
of manner,"4 to the village's mores as well as the beginnings of
assimilation into its society.
Notes 1. Camus. The Myth of Sisyphus. p. 126.
2. Camus. Myth. p. 129.
3. Ibid. p. 129. Camus.
4. Ibid. p. 130. Camus.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 1996-2006
Steve Hoenisch and Criticism.Com. All rights reserved.
| Home
| Site Map
| Search
| Privacy Policy
| Top |